DIY Brooch Bracelet. What you need to look for is a bracelet blank with abezel (the tray to put something on or in). Beyond easy and cheap if you use coupons. Tutorial at Happy Hour Projects here.
DIY Anthropologie Inspired Skys End Earrings (Anthropologie on LEFT here $70, orig. $128, DIY RIGHT). I personally like the DIY version better, and you can also use different color rhinestone/crystal chains and beads. If you are interested in making jewelry this tutorial from smallgoodthings is so detailed, with meticulous step by step instructions and large photos, you cannot mess up!
DIY 52 Reasons I Like You Tutorial. I originally posted this tutorial by Little Gray Fox here (when she posted her deck of cards’ book on Craftster). She now has a real tutorial and more photos posted on her site, Little Gray Fox here.
DIY EASY Semi Handmade Heart Soap. This is the quick and dirty (easy) version where you don’t have to melt anything and you already probably have all the ingredients at hand. You can customize this for all holidays. Tutorial from Under the Table and Dreaming here.